Pick Comparison

Current version of the page has been reviewed and is approved ().


In the context of the electric guitar experiments, the influence of different thicknesses of picks was also compared. Picks are typically used to enable a louder and more defined attack on the string with the same amount of force. The thickness of the pick also affects the sound. Additionally, the material used significantly impacts the tone.

Experimental Setup

Amplifier settings as used in experiment
To illustrate these differences, a specific selection of picks with thicknesses of 0.88 mm, 1 mm, 1.5 mm, 1.38 mm, and 2 mm was chosen. These were compared using a Fender Stratocaster (Mexico - 3x Single Coil pickups). The guitar was played through a Marshall JVM 410H amplifier, connected to an MR1960B 4x12 cabinet with custom speaker configuration. The sound samples were recorded using a Shure SM57 microphone.


Pick Thicknesses

Picks used for experiment (from left to right: 0,88mm 1mm 1,5mm 1,38mm 2mm)
For the experiment, the pick thicknesses were compared by playing each one directly above Neck, Middle, and Bridge pickups. Only the Neck pickup was active. The following audio examples were created and labeled by the thickness of the pick used:

0.88mm.wav
1.5mm.wav
1.38mm.wav
1mm.wav
2mm.wav


Guitarist:Phillip Wisser


Direct Comparison of Picks

Pick Comparison: Neck Pickup


Pick Comparison: Middle Pickup

Common Pick Thicknesses

Thin Picks:
  • Low resistance when striking the strings.
  • Ideal for gentle strumming techniques.
  • Produces bright, light tones.
Medium Picks:
  • Balanced ratio of flexibility and resistance.
  • Suitable for various playing styles, from strumming to single notes.
  • Versatile sound character.
Thick Picks:
  • High resistance when striking the strings.
  • Suitable for precise picking and complex melodies.
  • Produces strong tones with clear attack.

Common Pick Styles

Standard Picks:
  • Triangular shape with rounded corners.
  • Generally suitable for various styles.
Jazz Picks:
  • Small, pointed shape.
  • Preferred by guitarists for fast solos and precise picking.
Nylon Picks:
  • Made from nylon material.
  • Produces softer tones, especially when strumming.
Celluloid Picks:
  • Traditional material with various designs.
  • Versatile and available in different thicknesses.
Metal Picks:
  • Harder materials such as steel or aluminum.
  • Produces clear tones and emphasizes overtones.
Finger Picks:
  • Metal or plastic tips that fit over the fingers.
  • Allows for precise fingerpicking with additional attack.
Cork/ Fabric Picks:
  • Designed for a very soft sound.
  • Commonly used for ukulele.